Earnings Report Magic
Friday, June 12th, 2009 by Reuben AdvaniEver wonder why certain public companies meet or beat the earnings number predicted by Wall Street research analysts? GE, Microsoft, Apple are just a few of many corporate behemoths that tend to impress analysts and investors quarter after quarter. So how are they able to consistently able to beat these numbers, even in a slow economy? Two factors contribute to this:
- Guidance
- Profit Smoothing
As much as we would like to believe that the stars align for such companies, the reality is that managing earnings is more a product of skill than divine intervention.
When it comes to guidance, corporate managers tend to under-promise and hope to over-deliver. It works something like this: Company X just released its quarterly earnings report and beat the consensus earnings number. The consensus number is the average of analysts’ prediction for net earnings (also referred to as net income, net profit or the bottom line). Company X was pleased to report that due to aggressive cost cutting, they were able to beat the consensus number by one penny per share (total net earnings divided by total shares of stock outstanding). Beating the estimate is always a good thing and will often drive the stock price higher. While analysts and investors rejoice, the corporate management pats itself on the back for achieving strong results.
So how did they pull this off? At the conclusion of last quarter, Company X purposely issued very conservative earnings guidance even though there were several large sales likely to close before the end of the quarter. To play it safe, they sought to keep expectations low knowing they could easily surpass them and push the stock price higher.
As it turned out, several of the planned sales fell through. Time to bring in the heavy artillery. In this case, the heaviest of all is profit smoothing. Company X can adjust the assumptions on non-cash gains and expenses to make the earnings number beat expectations. Still too low? Why not lower the charge against a bad loan portfolio? How about changing the depreciation schedule to lower the expense taken in the near term? Through some combination of non-cash adjustments, Company X is able to generate the right earnings number. Unfortunately, once in a while no amount of profit smoothing will save a company from a bad earnings number which is what happened to GE a few quarters ago. And when that happens, look out below!


weak banking sector